This is a companion piece to Tobias Gardner’s article ‘Sweepers, Suffrage, and the Shifting Language of Slavery in Industrial Sheffield, 1823–1848‘ recently published Open Access in History Workshop Journal 102.
In December 2025, Reform UK outlined its ambitions to reduce foreign aid by 90%. These plans mimic the Trump administration’s recent dismantling of the US Agency for International Development – a policy that could potentially lead to more than 14 million preventable deaths by 2030. Reform spokesperson Zia Yusuf’s justification was that previous governments had squandered billions on projects abroad while British citizens went ignored – spending taxpayers’ money, in effect, to ‘virtue signal’. Therefore, in the current populist environment, it has become common to smear international humanitarian concerns as performative acts that distract from domestic issues.
The phrase ‘virtue-signalling’ is redolent of the twenty-first century. The charge, however, is not new. Tensions between problems at home versus problems abroad have a lengthy history in British society and politics. During the 1830s, activists and political figures participated in similar debates. Over this decade, slavery was steadily abolished across the British Empire while industrialisation generated new domestic tensions. For some campaigners, abolition was just the opening move in a global mission against enslavement. For others, Britain – as a self-appointed liberty-loving nation – had done its job, and it was time to divert focus to issues within the industrial heartlands. Whether in a textile mill, cutlery workshop, or a chimney flue, conditions were undeniably bleak for many in the population. Indeed, from the works of Charles Dickens through to the 2012 Olympic opening ceremony, the ‘Condition-of-England question’ – as Thomas Carlyle famously coined it – still resonates in the popular imagination. What is often missing from this popular understanding is how Atlantic slavery influenced the discourse around British industrial oppression.

Drawn by E. Blore; engraved by G. Cooke. Wikimedia Commons.
Throughout the nineteenth century, domestic reformers regularly invoked comparisons between Britain’s industrial workers and enslaved Africans. These comparisons were often accompanied by a criticism of the hypocrisy (or possibly ‘virtue-signalling’) of evangelical abolitionists who supposedly paid little attention to the conditions of child labourers while they campaigned against chattel slavery elsewhere in the world. My article in HWJ 102 explores criticisms made by two such domestic reformers: Samuel Roberts, a Sheffield manufacturer and pamphleteer, and Ebenezer Elliott, a Rotherham poet and ironmaster.
Samuel Roberts was intimately familiar with the vocabulary of slavery. In the 1820s, he had been a staunch campaigner for British antislavery. Following the Abolition Act of 1833, Roberts argued that Britain had ended its complicity with Atlantic slavery and should refocus on domestic issues. He therefore turned his energies toward the climbing boys sent up British chimneys and to the New Poor Law of 1834, which expanded the infamous workhouse system. His chimney-sweep pamphlets targeted the Sheffield Ladies Antislavery Society, which had joined the international movement for universal emancipation. In an 1837 work, he ridiculed the ‘tender-hearted’ Ladies for overlooking juvenile ‘white slaves’ at home in favour of a ‘despised race… in a foreign market’. From Roberts’ racist perspective, the industrial oppression and disregard for welfare in Britain meant that the ‘well-dressed N***o’ would end up commiserating ‘British slaves.’
Ebenezer Elliot spent the same decade dedicated to overturning the Corn Laws, which protected hefty tariffs on foreign grain imports and maintained high bread prices for the British population – earning him the nickname the ‘Corn Law Rhymer’. Like Roberts, he was scathing towards universal abolitionists and extended his criticisms to philanthropic social movements across the British Empire, particularly from the missionary community which was very active in Sheffield. Lecturing to an audience of around 10,000 people in 1838, Elliott jeered at those who claimed to ‘love the people’ but ignored ‘miseries at their very doors’ and instead with their ‘telescopic eyes [agitated for] Hindoos, black slaves and the C*****s of Africa‘. This is a trope Dickens would make famous fourteen years later in the figure of Mrs Jellyby, whose gaze could take in nothing nearer than Africa while her own children tumbled down the stairs.
Both Roberts and Elliott, then, criticised international activism as moral righteousness that detracted from problems in Britain. However, this was not simply rhetorical point-scoring. As I argue in my article in HWJ 102, these quarrels between social movements over the competing claims of ‘home’ and ‘foreign’ slavery are also particularly important to examine at the local level. As the cases of Roberts and Elliott suggest, these debates were one of the main arenas in which ideas about race, class, gender and national belonging were worked out in the early nineteenth century.
Smearing those concerned about global oppression as ‘virtue-signallers’ was not necessarily radical. While Roberts and Elliott mocked the ‘telescopic eyes’ of their philanthropic middle-class peers, this never developed into supporting genuine political rights for the working class. Both fell out with local branches of the Chartist movement (a nationwide campaign for universal suffrage in the 1830-40s). Their attempts to expose the self-righteousness of universal antislavery and overseas missions ultimately left them vulnerable to criticism when they didn’t support constitutional change within Britain. Roberts and Elliott claimed to represent the oppressed ‘native’ British population, but their actions amounted to little more than charitable patronage.
Returning to Zia Yusuf’s comments about ‘virtue signalling’, then, indicates that the charge of selective philanthropy endures in British political discourse. The irony, of course, is that Reform UK has been embroiled in a range of scandals about international funding in recent months. While the party may denounce international aid as ‘virtue signalling’, it has spent the summer fielding questions about the influx of money from abroad – the very foreign philanthropy it claims to oppose. The histories of Samuel Roberts and Ebenezer Elliott indicate that activists and political figures in the early nineteenth century similarly navigated competing priorities between international and local problems. Within these debates, there was also a nativist inclination to tarnish global activism at best as morally self-serving, at worst as intentionally elitist. The criticism of sanctimony has long played an important role in British political rhetoric and will likely remain an irresistible tactic for those seeking to speak for ‘the people’.